Stories · as read on the Mining station
The Tow Truck Test: Aaron Tilton of SmartFi on Lending
SmartFi's Aaron Tilton on the 2022 lending collapse: growth that outran liquidity, unsustainable yields, and a token SmartFi says it will buy back.
Did the man who borrowed money for his tow truck still show up to work the next morning? Aaron Tilton, CEO of SmartFi, asked that question at Mining Disrupt Miami 2022, held July 26 to 28, 2022, a few weeks after Celsius came off the rails. His answer was yes. He still towed cars and he still had cash flow.
Bitcoin traded at $21,268 that week. Today it trades at $78,494. Tilton opened by playing Breaking Benjamin's song Simple Design, and the title was his thesis. Lending is not complicated, he said.
Celsius, Three Arrows Capital and others made it complicated, and SmartFi, which had been a counterparty to some of them, did not take the risk they took. SmartFi's first customers were miners, in Europe, Asia, South America, the United States and Canada. Tilton said that in 2018 Celsius was about the same size as SmartFi, and by his account it reached a peak asset value of 20 billion dollars in about 36 months. Then the price fell.
In his words, "where do you go to sell 20 billion dollars worth of bitcoin to stop out the risk there is nobody that'll take that." He said Celsius always paid about two percent above everybody else on its interest accounts, so it had to put the assets into riskier and riskier places, including DeFi and Luna. It started to look a little like a Ponzi scheme, he said. His rule was simple: "if a promised return is too good to be true it's too good to be true." SmartFi turned down projects that wanted its assets, because it could not quantify the risk. Instead, about one-third of SmartFi's portfolio at times sat in real estate and equipment loans.
A real business, Tilton said, cannot grow from zero to 20 billion dollars in 36 months, but it also does not fall to zero in two weeks. SmartFi funds those loans with a token that carries a buyback guarantee. If the token falls below what you paid, you can bring it back after a one-year lock-up and SmartFi says it will buy it back at your purchase price. Tilton called that the best of fiat banking and the best of crypto.
He also said SmartFi had done more than a billion dollars in loans and transactions with mining companies, and had been testing its own blockchain for about two years, so that users could mine the interest from its loans. In the question period he described how a trade desk spots a lender in trouble: the counterparty starts asking for different deals at different rates. SmartFi stopped trading with those firms about a month into the trouble. The full story is on Mining Disrupt at miningdisrupt dot com, and many more like it play around the clock on Bitcoin Radio.