Stories · as read on the AI station
Proof That Proof of Work Works
Mining Disrupt Miami 2022 panelists argue the opposition to Proof of Work is about control, and that its real world cost is what gives Bitcoin its strength.
Sixty percent of the network's capacity goes offline almost overnight, and not a single block or transaction fails. That was the example at the heart of a panel recorded at Mining Disrupt Miami 2022, held from July 26 to 28, 2022. At that time, Bitcoin traded at $21,268. By October 2026, it was $83,769.
The panel was titled Proof Proof of Work Works, and it was moderated by Ben Gagnon of Bitfarms, then the company's chief mining officer. He opened with a simple question. The industry was 13 years old, every block and every transaction had been processed, and there had been no disruptions. So what is the opposition to Proof of Work in the first place?
Alex Brammer, who had just moved to Talen Energy, answered first. The arguments, he said, are couched in terms of emissions and investor protection, but the real issue is control. As he put it, "proof-of-work really though is the thing that because it is uh truly disintermediating some of the most powerful institutions and people in the world."
One panelist argued that the world already lives under a version of the alternative. In his words, "we're living in a world uh that is proof of stake by another name and it's and it's you know fiat-based central banking." In that world, he said, it is cheap to create money and cheap to manipulate the most important price signal, the price of money itself.
Gagnon pointed to the China mining ban as the greatest test the network has faced. Sixty percent went offline, and everything still moved. Brammer added that miners reallocated within 12 months and restored full performance with significantly lower emissions intensity. Another panelist noted that today, a 51 percent attack is implausible simply because of the chips, power, containers and locations it would take.
The panel also covered energy. Panelists described mining on associated gas from oil wells, including as far north as the Northwest Territories in Canada, and argued that Proof of Work is the only incentive that exists to reduce flare gas emissions. One panelist described mining loads in Texas that curtail when needed as almost a reverse peaker plant. And looking ahead, one panelist said, "without bitcoin mining the energy transition will not happen uh once that is widely understood and the regulatory hedwoods become regulatory tailwinds."
The panelists closed on a shared task: translating these technical details into simple terms for people outside the industry, from neighbors to congressional staffers.
Scot Johnson of Digital Shovel and Ethan Vera, then CEO of Luxor Technology, were also on the panel.
The full story is on Intelligence Disrupt at intelligencedisrupt dot com, and many more like it play around the clock on Bitcoin Radio.